Tonight The X Factor’s final four compete in the
semi-finals vying for a spot in next week’s finale. Three of our four judges
have acts remaining in the competition as the last contestant from Team Demi was
eliminated last week. This evening each act will perform twice, and the judges
will have no say in which three acts will advance to next week. Mario promises an
intense evening, and Khloe knows how to say her own name. Let’s not delay this any longer.
Act: Tate Stevens
Team: LA
Song: “Bonfire” by Craig Morgan
Tate got to
choose his own song this evening, which he seems very excited about. Clearly he’s
had some creative differences with LA but is too much of a gentleman to say so. I’ve
never heard this song, but he says the word “rednecks” and the camera cuts to
LA in a cowboy hat, so I’m already entertained. Tate is very into the song, he
works the stage, and he really looks like a country superstar tonight. Nicely
done.
Judges Say: Britney doesn’t think that
was Tate’s best performance (because he is Carly’s biggest competition). Demi
disagrees and says it was a winning performance. Simon loves that Tate chose a
song that he would want to record, and it was one of his favorite Tate performances.
LA says Tate lit the stage on fire (literally). Khloe asks LA if he likes “wearing
a country hat," and I consider bludgeoning myself with my laptop.
---------------------------------------------
Act: Carly Rose Sonenclar
Team: Britney
Song: “Your Song” by Elton John
Carly is
trying to regain that number 1 spot this week and I love that she chose this
song. The first half of the performance is a little low and slightly snoozy,
but then Carly moves across a catwalk and owns the rest of the song. Not my
favorite of Carly’s performances, but she is still my favorite contestant.
Judges Say: LA is no longer wearing his
country hat. He says Carly did things with that song that he’s never heard done
before. Demi reminds us that she doesn’t have any contestants left, and then
she tells Carly that she’s very predictable. On the flip side, this was Demi’s
favorite performance. Huh? Simon thought
Carly sang a beautiful version of a fantastic song. Britney is very proud to be
her mentor.
---------------------------------------------
Act: Emblem3
Team: Simon
Song: “Baby I Love Your Way” by Peter Frampton
The boys
have been criticized for not commanding the stage, and this week the one in the
backwards hat says they “are deep in the game” and want to win. They start the
song laying down on the stage (not what I think was meant by commanding) and
they resume the normal standing next to one another and bopping up and down.
The blond one that shouldn’t sing moves around in the crowd a bit, but otherwise
it’s the same stuff. The audience looooooves it though.
Judges Say: LA says the guys just had
their first $5 million moment. I must have missed it. Britney thinks the
performance was special and the group has really grown up. Demi loved it, and I’m
so confused. Simon says the performance reminded him of their very first
audition, and they absolutely deserve to move on to the finals
---------------------------------------------
Act: Fifth Harmony
Team: Simon
Song: “Anything Can Happen” by Ellie
Goulding
Fifth
Harmony is still bummed about being in the bottom two last week and they want
to be sure to show America what a fun girl group they are this week. The girls
sit at an Alice in Wonderland type
party table, and God help the kid on the right with the bow. Even Minnie Mouse
would say “hell no” to that accessory. Fashion choices aside, the girls sound
great and move around the stage far more tonight than they have in previous
weeks. I really like it, and I hope this gets them a spot in the finale.
Judges Say: LA thinks this was Fifth
Harmony’s best vocal performance. Woohoo! Brit Brit loved everything about it. Demi
thinks they pulled out the sparkle they needed this week, whatever that means. Simon tells the girls
they are the underdogs, but after that performance...“anything can happen.” See
what he did there?
---------------------------------------------
Act: Tate Stevens
Team: LA
Song: “Fall” Clint Walker
LA put the
hat back on. Just throwing that out there.
I’m 0 for 2 tonight with Tate because I don’t know this song either.
This is another ballad that he dedicates to his wife, who really might be the
luckiest woman ever. I feel that guys like Tate are few and far between, and that's just a shame. I prefer
Tate’s first performance to this one, but as far as country ballads go, this is
probably his best “emotional” performance.
Judges Say: Britney says Tate has had
some hits and misses, and this was a hit. Demi thinks Tate is so amazing and
talented. Simon says he has made his mark and deserves to be in the finale.
LA believes Tate is consistently great each time he performs.
---------------------------------------------
Act: Carly Rose Sonenclar
Team: Britney
Song: “Imagine” by John Lennon
There’s
nothing quite like a young, gorgeous voice singing this song. Yes, I am also
referring to David Archuleta’s version and I’m not ashamed of it. However,
Carly goes the extra mile here, playing the piano to start (rather confidently I might add) and then rising to unleash
those ridiculously awesome notes on us. She’s just unreal. Carly finishes the
song back at the piano, and I am so impressed by how polished she is as a
vocalist.
Judges Say: LA thinks Carly took her
artistic abilities up a notch by playing the piano. Demi says the only predictable
thing about the performance was that it was amazing. Simon wishes she had just
stayed at the piano because getting up and down and having the chorus behind her was a
little too much. Britney thinks it’s time for Carly to go beyond this stage and
compete with the biggest stars in the world.
---------------------------------------------
Act: Emblem3
Team: Simon
Song: “Hey Jude” by The Beatles
Ohhhh boy.
They’re letting the blond one who shouldn’t sing play the guitar again. During
the first half of the song the guys stay pretty true to the melody, and I am
generally okay with it. Once the second half starts there are some liberties
that I don’t really love…and then they get to the “na na na nas” and I
start singing “no no no no.” Don’t get me wrong – this wasn’t as bad as I
thought it would be, but Carly just slayed “Imagine.” This doesn’t really compare.
|
Case and point. |
Judges Say: LA tells the group they are
teen heartthrobs like The Beatles. Britney thinks it was an “A List” performance
and they should take a bow. Demi agrees that the performance was great but is
hesitant to compare Emblem3 to The Beatles. And she SHOULD be. Simon is so proud of what Emblem3 has achieved
tonight, saying they nailed both songs.
---------------------------------------------
Act: Fifth Harmony
Team: Simon
Song: “Impossible” by Shontelle
I am really
hoping these girls have a moment here. Fifth Harmony switches the song up a
little by singing parts of it in Spanish, which is a clever idea, but I
honestly would have enjoyed the song just as much (if not more) without the random
switch in languages. As much as I’m rooting for them, I’m not sure that this
will get the girls where they want to be next week.
Judges Say: LA didn’t like the song
choice, and he doesn’t think this was a performance worthy of the finals.
Britney drops the hammer and pretty much tells them to pack their bags. Ouch.
Demi says this comes down to the fans and hopes that they come through for
Fifth Harmony. Simon thinks the song was the right way to go and hopes we see them next week as well.
---------------------------------------------
Mario feels
the need to speak Spanish (hey – I can do it too!) and then reminds us how
critical it is to vote. Khloe stays pretty quiet and that’s exactly how it
should be. Only three acts can advance, and I am hoping for a Carly/Tate/Fifth Harmony finale. Sorry, Emblem3 fans. We’ll find out who stays and who goes during tomorrow’s results show.
Til then!